Book review: Romantic Comedy / Curtis Sittenfeld

Romantic Comedy / Curtis Sittenfeld

I don’t know what it is, but this is another book I’ve had lying in my book stack for little over a year and never truly felt like picking it up. Until now. I was actually looking for an item that fit any of the remaining items of the reading challenge list, but go figure, this one spoke to me. I sat down, opened the book and before I knew it I was halfway through.
This book is everything main character Sally wants romantic comedies to be: smart, sharp, and funny, with imperfect main characters. It’s a bit meta but it works. Obviously, The Night Owls sketch comedy show that Sally is a writer for, is based on Saturday Night Live. The workplace descriptions were a lot, but because the work is intense and the only thing in Sally’s life, along with her best friends being on the show as well, it makes sense. And this isn’t a normal job; it requires less pages to describe a generic Human Resources department or law firm than it is the behind-the-scenes of a sketch show.
Sally’s sketches and her sense of humor are really good, and the fact that she of all people, falls head over heals in love with the host-of-the-week hottie singer, Noah Webster, is ironic and funny. (There was still the expected cliché of the handsome singer being alone and sad in his cage of gold and admiration, but, to stick with the story, Noah plays it off well.)
Noah is instantly attracted to Sally, and vice versa, but because Sally is a “normal” woman and not a twenty-two-year old model, she considers Noah out of her reach and focuses on a professional relationship instead. Noah decides to talk to her about her prejudice after the show has wrapped, and shocked to be confronted this way with her own behavior, Sally lashes out at him and they don’t see each other anymore after that.
Then the pandemic hits and Sally receives an email from Noah. Being stuck home alone in his mansion he’s had time to reflect and wonders if they should talk things out.
Sally, who has moved home to Kansas City after feeling claustrophobic in her New York City apartment, welcomes the email with surprise and is happy with the distraction from lockdown life. (Living with her senior citizen stepfather Jerry, life has been focused on chair yoga, walking the dog, and early dinners.)
They talk things out over email, and the email correspondence is fun to read. It’s an easy way to have Sally and Noah explain their behavior and their past, without having them to go into long, winding speeches. Then Noah asks her if she wants to visit him in California and because she doesn’t dare to ask what his intensions are, she drives to California without knowing if it’s going to be a platonic stay or something more.
It quickly becomes clear that a platonic relationship is not what Noah has in mind, and their “pod” becomes a love bubble.
One day during a hike they are pulled out of the bubble by paparazzi waiting for them in the car park. Noah’s reaction is to let go of Sally’s hand and encouraging her to hurry to the safety of his car. Sally misreading the reaction nearly blows up the relationship but they manage to talk it out and even prepare a statement for their agents to publish.
The reactions to the pictures on social media play on Sally’s insecurities, and confirm to her that the relationship makes no sense. So, she takes a break and moves into a hotel for some distance, and to clear her head.
A few days into her pout-and-run she gets a call that Jerry hasn’t been seen in two days, and her aunt fears he’s been struck down by Covid. Because the aunt’s husband is in a high-risk category and they’ve basically been in strict quarantine since the outbreak of the pandemic, Sally gets over herself and calls Noah to let him know she needs to travel home. They put aside their differences and Noah not only arranges a private jet for her, but travels along with her and they become full-time carers for Jerry and dog Sugar, and stay until Jerry is fully recovered.

The book is divided in to two parts (2018 and 2020), with an epilogue (2023).
For anyone eager never to think back to pandemic times, better ignore this book, because it plays at the height of the lockdowns, that first summer when nobody was going anywhere and if you had to, it seemed like the apocalypse had happened with the empty streets and the masks and gloves, and not allowed to stay anywhere inside.
This is, of course, as the title says, a romantic comedy. It’s an easy breezy read and if you like anything based on Pride & Prejudice, you’ll like this.
There is a meet-cute in a meeting room (ha), conflict, and a misunderstanding. There is an invite to stay at a mansion (it’s not Pemberley but still), and there is even a big romantic gesture at the end. Also, a feisty but insecure heroine, and a romantic non-player hero, that you’ll be rooting for by the end of the first chapter.

Book review: In a Thousand Different Ways / Cecilia Ahern

In a Thousand Different Ways / Cecelia Ahern

Alice Kelly is eight years old when she comes home from school and finds her mother at home, completely blue. In a panic, she calls in the emergency services, who find that her mother is merely asleep. Confused, Alice checks again: her mother is still blue. But the color isn’t just on her, it’s around her, like a veil trailing behind her.
This is the first time Alice sees colors but from that moment on, it doesn’t go away; it only ever grows. She starts seeing the colors of other people, first her brothers, then the children and teachers in school as well. It scares her because she can see the effect of colors on the people around them and is afraid to get other people’s colors on her. She starts wearing sunglasses because the intensity of the colors gives her headaches.
Alice grows up in a dysfunctional home: her father has walked out and her mother can’t handle herself, much less her three children. When Alice speaks out about seeing colors and thinks she should see a doctor, Lily (Alice refuses to call her mom because she never acts like one), and younger brother Ollie don’t believe her and make fun of her. Older brother Hugh does believe her, and tries to help her to find out what is causing it. Hugh’s colors are pink and when Lily’s dark and angry colors try to get to him, they are deflected off him. It mesmerizes Alice. Lily’s colors do find an eager recipient in Ollie, who soaks them up and takes them on. This terrifies Alice.
The story follows Alice as she navigates through life, seeing colors but not always understanding what they mean: there are new colors, or unique colors. She sees colors of plants and trees as well and goes to parks to breathe in the calm colors of nature to escape the chaotic people colors. Her brother Hugh calls her skill a talent, but Alice calls it a curse.
When Alice starts to abuse her skills in a career in sales, it comes at a price and she crashes hard.
After this, she needs to re-learn, find a healthier way to deal with the skill, and slowly readjusts. It’s the beginning of something different and although Alice is still being pulled back to her old life by her mother, she is able to distance herself from that as well, moving forward and focusing on her own development.
And then one day she is startled to find a man who has no colors. This man becomes an obsession because she doesn’t know what it means. She is hopeful it’s only a good sign, but whatever it means, she won’t know for sure until she sees the man again. So she travels the train over and over, until she meets him there again, still without color. This time, she decides to follow him, to find out what it means.

This book had been lying in my tbr cabinet for a year. It was part of the big “spending spree of the summer of twenty-three” and I was disappointed in myself every time I picked it up and moved it aside to take out another book; I’ve loved books by this author without a fail (which was why I hadn’t hesitated buying this title) yet I couldn’t bring myself to start this one. I guess it’s down to the sixth sense of a bookworm, that tells us when it’s the right moment for a read. And thankfully I never force myself into reading anything, because the right moment was simply not until now, and I got to enjoy it oh so much.
The book is divided into sections named after colors and halfway through they start to mean more so you sense what is going to happen and I braced myself when I read “white”. (I went back to check on the earlier section colors because at the time they hadn’t meant as much.)
Alice is a great character and interesting to follow through life: she’s flawed, confused, and scared. She learns and grows and wants to be loved.
The story goes back and forth between past and present, but it’s easy to keep track.
The book is so nicely written, and pulled me in from the first page. It has the same feel as the other books I’ve read by this author: it’s warm, it’s slightly magical, and it’s real at the same time. If that’s something you like to read, please add this to your tbr. And read it whenever you feel the time is right.

Book review: Night Train to Marrakech / Dinah Jefferies

Night Train to Marrakech / Dinah Jefferies

Together with friend M I recently took a spontaneous trip to Marrakech, and we enjoyed the heck out of this wonderful city: the colours, the sounds, the smells. The wonderful people, rich history, and beautiful buildings. We had an amazing time.
So, when I spotted this book by an author I’d read before and liked, it was clear that I was destined to read it.

Night Train to Marrakech is set in 1966, when Vicky Baudin discovers she has a grandmother who lives in Marrakech. Having finished her degree in fashion with a dissertation on Yves Saint Laurent, Vicky is eager to travel to the Moroccan city during her summer break: she plans to meet her grandmother and the French designer in one swoop. Arriving by train from Tangier, she quickly realizes that she’s arrived in a world unlike anything she has experienced before.
Her grandmother Clemence lives outside the city in the Atlas Mountains where she has completely renovated a medieval estate and turned it into an impressive home. And a great place to hide secrets.
Clemence’s cool reception is not the welcome Vicky had expected and it rattles her. So when Clemence offers to set Vicky up in a friend’s riad (traditional home) in the city instead, she eagerly jumps on the opportunity. Within in a day in the old city Vicky has made connections because it’s a place where everybody knows someone who knows someone, but she is surprised to learn that they are all warning her to keep a low profile and not express political views. Tension is simmering but Vicky is not politically aware or involved, and keeps focused on following her own dreams. A few days later her British cousin Beatrice arrives in the city as well and the two women enjoy being tourists in a new place. They get invited to a groovy party (it’s the sixties after all) where Vicky is left disappointed in her run-in with YSL. Things go from bad to worse after that, and witnessing a crime sobers them up quickly. Not sure who to trust anymore, they flee the city for the safety of Clemence’s mountain home but never reach the place: half-way there they get into an accident. Beatrice walks off to find help, and Vicky stays with their injured driver. Beatrice is in another incident and unable to make it back to the accident spot, and the story then turns into a dramatic mystery: what happened to Bea? Bea’s parents travel to the city to help with the search, then an aunt and uncle follow as well. Vicky is being questioned by the police since this is the second incident she has been involved with in as many days, and her mother eventually travels to Marrakech as well.

In the meantime, Clemence is dealing with her elderly mother who is suffering from Alzheimer’s, and she’s afraid that the old lady will blurt out the secrets they have been keeping for a long time. She’s also receiving notes that indicate someone knows about a big secret from her past. Then there is a man from that past reappearing who clearly is the bad guy, as well as another man, she was once in love with. This Theo is an American and it’s hinted at that he is a “spook”.
The political situation in the country plays a big part for the story, as it catapults the first incidents and it originally sets the scene with the simmering tensions. But this part of the story is abandoned when the family drama becomes the leading storyline.
And yes, those horrible situations exist that people get picked up and disappear never to be heard of again, their disappearance never explained, but it felt a bit easy to use them like that in this story; it felt like the political murders were only used to propel the story forward and that seemed a bit harsh. These were people that Vicky had befriended, and along with Theo’s presence, it could have easily been explored more what the background of all the tension was, what the stakes were, and why it was so dangerous. (It’s explained in a very quick and flimsy way.)
But with Clemence’s past catching up with her, Vicky’s mom’s background, and Bea’s mom’s background, there was just a lot of old drama that overshadowed the present. There is also a lot of movement: people going back and forth between the mountain residence and the city, then to a hotel, back to the mountains. And because there were so many different people at different places, none of their stories was going deep enough to fully care about.
For example, one the aunts is an experienced climber and she goes up in the mountains searching for Beatrice, but she was just left up in those mountains for chapters on end and I completely forgot about her until another character wondered what was keeping her.

All in all, this book left me underwhelmed. There was a lot of story with a lot of characters. At times it almost read like a soap opera. The story which had started out with a twenty-something setting out on a journey that will change her life forever, turned into a family drama that completely overshadowed this main character’s development: everybody had a story to tell and it was just too much.
It wasn’t until reaching the acknowledgements at the end of the book that it became clear that this was actually book three of a trilogy (Women of War). That explained the wrap-up chapter for sure, and from the synopses of the other books provided, I realized how all the characters were brought in to connect the stories in this final work, but having read this under the assumption it was a stand-alone, I was at times puzzled about characters. When I later checked to see if had missed something, I only found a mention of the trilogy on the author introduction page. Because I’d already read works from this author, I had skipped that page. I know that’s on me, but I really don’t think that’s enough to indicate work is part of a series: I don’t think it’s too much to ask to mention this on the cover, title page, or somewhere in the summary on the back. Knowing a book is part of a series reads differently, even if you haven’t read the other books (yet).
I was also a bit confused about the title and the cover art. Gorgeous as they are, they didn’t connect to the story. The desert plays no part in the story. The summary on the back cover mentions an “epic journey” and yes, travelling to Marrakech in those days involved taking a long train ride from Tangier or Casablanca. But within two paragraphs, Vicky arrives in Marrakech and the whole journey really plays no part in the character development.
All characters that are travelling into Marrakech take this train but it’s only mentioned in passing for them. The station also plays no central role in the story, and it’s just a place to go pick up new characters.
Then I thought the train must be a metaphor but I couldn’t really make that fit either. If the “epic journey” is meant figuratively, I don’t find it fitting either because the main character just isn’t going through enough development to make that stick.

The book’s strong parts were the descriptions, the way that the city is described, the experience of being in the souk for the first time, the intense heat, the colours and the smells. The riad’s, the Atlas Mountains, and the food; it was all spot-on and it took me right back.
I really wanted to love this book, and maybe my expectations were too high, but it just left me disappointed.
If you have this book on your reading wish-list, I strongly suggest reading the other titles of the series first (Daughters of War, and The Hidden Palace) because I don’t think this really works as a stand-alone and it might help understand some of the plot choices better.

Book review: Black Cake / Charmaine Wilkerson

Black Cake / Charmaine Wilkerson

This turned out to be one of those books that made me forget about the plenty of other books I have lying around yet to be read: it arrived, curiously I opened it on the first page, and next thing I knew, I’d read 70 odd pages. I was hooked from the beginning and loved it.
And I don’t care if this makes me appear shallow, but I also loved the cover art, with the optical illusion of the almost-3d spoon.

Black Cake is a family drama slash family mystery.
It starts with estranged brother and sister Byron and Benny meeting again for the first time in years. It’s a forced reunion, brought on by the death of their mother, Eleanor.
Eleanor has left them two things: a Caribbean black cake, and a recording of her life story.
As the story unravels, it turns out that their mother’s life was not quite what they thought it was.
Not only are the siblings grieving the loss of their last parent, but they are struggling with each other’s company and have to deal with the resentment and confusion that simmers underneath the surface.
It’s difficult to divulge further without giving away spoilers, so all I’ll say is that the story involves island life, swimming, murder, and perseverance. Also in the mix are colonialism, being different, and outsiders. Add love, and loyalty. Dust with a sprinkling of identity, finding yourself and staying true to yourself. Serve with acceptance and forgiveness.

There is a lot of story and there are a lot of characters to keep track of, but it’s never too much. It’s well written, and the chapters are (at times very) short and that makes it easy to forget about the real world, and just keep reading. One more chapter, one more, one more. If you can afford to lose time like that, I strongly recommend diving into this story.

Note the 1st : no apology for the abundant use of puns should be expected.
Note the 2nd: I do want to acknowledge that the book was turned into a series (streaming on Disney+ in the NL; check for your own location if not here) which seems to have good reviews. I cannot confirm nor deny that as the book was just too good for me to get into the series.

Book review: Over my dead body / Maz Evans

Over My Dead Body / Maz Evans

Meet Miriam Price. Forty-something doctor, unhappy wife, slightly unpleasant woman. Dead.
The police have ruled her death accidental but Miriam knows it was not because she was there. Also, she’s still there, stuck in Limbo and not allowed to move on to the afterlife until she either reaches her death date, or solves the mystery of her murder. Because there’s no way Miriam is going to hang around in orange dungarees for the next fifty years, she sets about to solving her murder. But it’s not easy figuring things out when you’re a lowest-level ghostly figure, so she needs outside help. The only person who can see and hear her, is her elderly neighbour Winnie. The problem with that is that the two can’t stand each other and that asking for help from the person she sent an envelope filled with glitter as recently as the day before her death, is not easy. The good news though, is that Winnie is an amateur sleuth and up for the adventure, if only to get rid of her annoying neighbour for good.
Throughout the story you learn more about the antics the women have been up to and it’s hilarious. Winnie and Miriam are nothing alike but driven by the same moral standards, which makes them the perfect odd couple detective team.

Like in a lot of ghost stories, Miriam gets to stalk her friends and family and glance behind the curtain of the people in her life, and of course, she learns that not all is what it seemed: her lover, her best friend, her brother, they all have a reason for their behaviour in relation to her, and despite her self-awareness this still catches her by surprise. That felt a bit too much of a cliché to me.
Everything else though, is really well done. Miriam is grouchy and sarcastic and her commentary is sharp as spikes. Her brother (“more woke than a shop full of alarm clocks”), Millennial medical students (“snowflakes” she refers to as No. 1, No. 2 and No. 3) and Diagnosis Murder especially, bring out the worst (and best) in her.

This book had me snorting and laughing out loud and Miriam and Winnie’s exchanges were the biggest contributors to this. The book is a breezy read, doesn’t get scary, and although I could predict the ending by the time I reached the second chapter, I enjoyed this book a lot.
This very fun read was exactly what I needed after the slightly more angsty books I’ve been reading of late; it was the perfect palate cleanser.

Book review: The Librarianist / Patrick deWitt

The Librarianist / Patrick deWitt

I absolutely loved the out-thereness of deWitt’s The Sisters Brothers, French Exit, and Undermajordomo Minor. With bonus points for cover art. Although the cover art is easily as wonderful, The Librarianist has a very different feel to it, as this story is less out-there and more barely-there.

The story is about Bob, the retired librarian(ist) from the title. Bob lived his life according to a strict schedule which existed of work, mainly, and not much of a personal life otherwise. Bob is the ultimate loner, spending his entire life in the same house. Routine is everything to him.
Then, on his daily one-mile walk, he finds an elderly woman lost, staring into the freezer of a corner shop. She is wearing a badge, so he returns her to the assisted-living home where she is registered, and this leads to Bob becoming a volunteer there.
The people at the home are quite the characters, which Bob isn’t, and they aren’t interested in him nor what he has to offer (book readings, starting with the great Russians).
Slowly but surely Bob’s past is revealed and it turns out that his loner-ship is a natural state of being. Bob was an only child, he didn’t know his father, and never had any friends.
That is, until he starts working at the local public library where he meets Ethan. Ethan is everything Bob is not: charismatic, dashing and outgoing.
The library is also where he meets his wife Connie. She is pretty and sociable; the yin to Bob’s yang. Bob grounds both Ethan and Connie, but their personalities need to fly and it’s not a spoiler to say that it doesn’t take long before Bob is a loner once again.
The things that happen to Bob, truly happen to him and he is never really active in anything. He’s the ultimate stoic: whatever happens, he just shrugs and trudges on.
The two exceptions to this are his decision to become a volunteer at the assisted-living home, and the time when as a kid he ran away from home. He got onto a bus and a train, heading for the Oregon coast. Halfway through the train trip, two traveling performers join him on the journey and accept him as a stowaway, but from then on out, he loses his momentum and decision-making skills: the ladies invite him to come along with them and he does. He doesn’t really make any choices any more, he just goes along with everything. If ever there was a follower, it was Bob. That his only real decisions took place at the beginning and near-end of his life are like bookends to the story of Bob, and totally fitting.

The beginning and end were the stronger parts for me, as I found the middle part a bit slow. I think if I re-read this, I might feel different about it, as it was mostly because I kept waiting for the part where things took a turn and went wild. And they just never did.
That’s not to say this isn’t a good story. It really is. It’s also funny, in a very dry way. It’s just very normal compared to the other work I’d read by this author, and I guess I wasn’t prepared for that. So let this be a warning for others: do not expect this book to be outrageous. This book is as calm and solid as its protagonist.

Book review: Weirdo / Sara Pascoe

Weirdo / Sara Pascoe

This book is about Sophie, the self-proclaimed weirdo of the title.
I didn’t think Sophie is actually that weird, mainly she is just stuck and doesn’t quite know how to get herself moving on.
Sophie is thirty-two and stuck in a job that is not the worst job ever (she escaped that one already), but far away from her dream job. She doesn’t know what that dream job is, she just wants to be famous, and has a habit of narrating the things that happen to her as if she were the guest of a talk show.
She’s not just stuck in her career, but also in a relationship. She’s living with Ian because he is the easy option, while Chris is the one that got away. Literally: she even chased him to Australia at one point, but by the time she found him there, he was already in a relationship with someone else. Then there’s James, the man she left at the time to chase after Chris: she only informed him that she was traveling when she touched down in Sydney. By then she’d also created a stink of her finances and spent all the money she’d borrowed. She’s been paying back her debts slowly and not so-surely, and now Chris is back in town and his arrival has her all confused and interested again.
James in the meantime, started a relationship with Sophie’s sister, so now she’s still faced with him whenever there’s a family gathering.

All in all, Sophie was more a mess than she was weird to me. She’s floating through life, and accepts the crappy jobs and the crappy men as if she has no other choice, but if she put in a little bit of effort and believe in herself, she could take control and do much better on both fronts. It takes 320 pages for Sophie to come to that conclusion and that was a bit on the long side. Sophie did feel very real though, her problems and feelings are genuine, and her observations are at times sharp, dark, and funny. They reveal the person she could be if only she gave things a decent try.
The story is interrupted by letters and notifications through which you learn more about her life. It’s a concept that’s nothing new but does manage to lift the story up at times because it can feel dragged down a bit. The letters from and concerning Sophie’s sister are the most outrageous ones and confirmed what I already knew: Sophie might be lacking a bit of spirit and self-belief but she’s not the weirdest person out there.

Overall this book is solid but middle-of-the-pack, and scores an “okay” for me.
If you like your main character to be plucky with a can-do attitude, leave this book be. If you like your main character to be a bit different / an odd-ball, this will be a good read.

Reading challenge 2024 – No. 5

No. 5: A book I started but never finished
The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue / V.E. Schwab

I remember I bought this book during one of the lockdowns because I thought I deserved a treat and I was so happy when it arrived (remember when a trip to the mailbox was the highlight of the day?), that I started it right away. I really don’t know why I never got very far in it, other than it being a big book coming in at over 500 pages, and during pandemic times I had the attention span of a confused gold fish. I found the Bookdepository (RIP) bookmarker still stuck between pages 55-56 and I vaguely remembered what I’d read, but the details eluded me, so I started over from the beginning.

This is a book that has everything going for it: gorgeous cover, great lay-out, and nice print. Yes, it’s big, but once I committed properly, I blew through it and this time around finished it within a weekend. The writing is easy, and Addie is a great character.
The story starts in 1714 when Adeline LaRue lives in a small village in France. Her parents are relieved that at twenty-three she finally is getting married, but Adeline, who doesn’t even like the man, fears that marriage will leave her virtually chained to the village, and she is desperate to find a last-minute escape. In her desperation she makes a deal with the devil and in return for her soul, he gives her freedom and with that a chance to live the life she’s always wanted for as long as she wants.
But you don’t “just” make a deal with the devil and Adeline soon discovers that she should have been more careful with her words because the downside to her deal is, that nobody remembers her. The devil gave her the “ultimate freedom” of not being remembered. She forever has to introduce herself and cannot even use her own name. She also cannot create anything herself; it gets erased right away.
It takes Addie some time to get used to this new way of living, but she manages. She leaves the village and goes to Paris where she learns it’s easier to be invisible amongst big crowds. She is visited there by “Luc” on the anniversary of their deal and he offers her an out: say the word and he’ll collect her soul and relieves her of the hard knock life she’s found herself in.
But Addie is not done living and refuses the offer. Every year on the anniversary Luc makes an appearance, and it’s something that Addie starts to look forward to, as he might be the devil, but he’s also the only one to remember her and call her by her real name. The two of them bicker and fight, and at times Luc punishes her by not showing up for a year or two.
This goes on for three hundred years, and lands us in the present of 2014. By then, Addie has been living in New York for quite some time, a city she enjoys as there is so much to discover. One of the things she discovers, is Henry. Henry works in a bookshop and when she goes back to return a book (after having it stolen a few days before), he recognizes her and chases her out of the shop (again).
The shock of someone remembering and recognizing her, has Addie startled more than being caught scamming. Thinking it’s a fluke, she doesn’t dare believe it actually is possible until she goes back to offer him an apology and he still remembers her. After spending three hundred years of reintroducing herself to people over and over again, slinking in and out of people’s lives, and nobody but the devil remembering her name, it is a welcome relief.
Although Henry clearly has a secret to hide himself, Addie is too relieved to be bothered by that. Their connection is immediate and intense and although she has to constantly introduce herself whenever they meet up with his friends, they both are fully committed to the relationship. She quickly decides she needs to trust Henry with her secret and he’s strangely easily okay with it all. She starts telling Henry everything, and he writes down her story, thinking this way she can leave her mark after all. But through her story, he discovers she’s already done that, having been a muse to painters, sculptures and musicians throughout the ages. Songs and pieces have been written and created because of her, and she shows up in paintings as “unknown woman”.
But the devil is due a visit because it’s been almost fifteen years since his last, and Addie knows they won’t have long. When Luc does show up, he shows up with the oomph you would expect from the devil. Just in time for the big finale.

And this is why I believe in second chances: I really liked this book the second time around!
The set-up is well done, and Addie and Luc are great characters. At times I wanted more depth from the historical settings and the people Addie meets, because they remain blurry. Although eventually that works, because it keeps the focus on Addie and Luc.
I have to admit I saw the twists at the end coming so the build-up to that felt a bit too slow and stretched out, and whatever story-telling was still happening, could have been left out for me. But this is a storybook-like telling, a great (love-hate) story, and totally enchanting. If any of that is your thing, don’t hesitate picking up this book!

The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue / V.E. Schwab

Reading challenge 2024 – No. 22

No. 22: A trilogy
Hell’s Library series / A.J. Hackwith

I don’t read a lot of trilogies. In all honesty I have a hard time thinking of another set of three books I read. So, yay for the reading challenge expending my reading experience!
The trilogy I ended up with was by total accident: I got the first book purely based on the title and cover art and only found out it was the first of three books when I looked up more information online. So, I happily made sure to get my hands on parts two and three as well, and here we are.

The Library of the Unwritten / A.J. Hackwith

Book 1: The Library of the Unwritten (2019)
Fantasy is not a genre I would pick under normal circumstances, because the world-building can be, dare I say it, tedious with too much detail. It’s a fine line between too much and not enough, and I guess the closer to the “known” the world setting is, the easier it is for the reader to be left to figure stuff out. For me that was the case with this book, as it is worldly unworldly.
The Library of the Unwritten, is part of Hell’s library, and is exactly what it sounds like: a library full of books that were started, but never finished. There are muses with pieces of text tattooed on their bodies, who live with damsels that fell out of their books and for whatever reason, couldn’t get back in.
The library users are demons and the like, allowed to use the materials inside the library but not take any of it out. There is a librarian in charge, doomed to keep the characters where they should be. Then one day Hero falls out of a book. Hero is classically handsome, and has one goal: to rescue his heroine, his author. He manages to escape the library and travel to earth, and when librarian Claire discovers this, she has to chase him through time and place to get him back into his book. That’s easier said than done, because she knows that when she leaves the library unguarded, well, all hell is about to break loose. And leaving the library is complicated enough, but getting back even more so, because the devil sends guards after them, and that’s not to get them back, but to eliminate them. Nobody is allowed to leave the library.
Claire doesn’t have to chase Hero on her own, because Brevity travels with her. Brevity is a muse, and library assistant. She has green hair and purple skin with text tattooed on it.
On their way they face challenges, engage in literature duels (awesome: participants hit each other with quotes), and need to track down a potion. They get stuck in a maze and have their souls weighted. And because the people they meet along the way all seem to have a hidden agenda, figuring out who’s friend or foe is difficult. All along they know that the situation in the Library is getting bad, and the urgency of finding their way back grows with every moment spent outside it.
I loved the settings (the gargoyle guarding the library, inter world loan system), and the characters were interesting enough to want to read more.

If you want to read this series, you might not want to continue this entry because what follows contains spoilers that might ruin your appetite and I’d hate to be responsible.

The Archive of the Forgotten / A.J. Hackwith

Book 2: The Archive of the Forgotten (2020)
This book opens where the first ended: the heroes have returned to the Library of the Unwritten and the dust of the big end fight is still settling. Claire is no longer the librarian, but has moved on to be the Arcanist, the keeper of the keeps of the Archive of the Forgotten. Fallen angel Rami has become her assistant. Muse Brevity is now the librarian of the Library of the Unwritten, with Hero as her assistant librarian.
When a mysterious inkwell appears on the library floor, they all go to check it out, and after reaching in, Claire’s hand turns completely ink black.
The gang needs to figure out how to help her, what effects the ink have on a human, and how to avoid the ink to spread. This sets off a chase across the realms once more for Hero and Rami. Claire stays at the Archives to establish what kind of ink it is. For this, she needs help from the damsels that live in the library but the relationship between Claire and Brevity is strained, making things move along slowly. It doesn’t help that Claire is distrusting of Brevity’s muse friend Probity.
Although everybody takes a different path, they all end up at the same place: the Dust Wing. This graveyard of books is where the finale takes place and we learn that it’s not about books, stories or writers, but souls. And that muses want to be their own person, and not just be connected to an artist.
We also learn that heroes should ask for permission to kiss someone because otherwise they’re no better than villains after all.
(Applause for that line.)

The story was easy to pick up because I knew the characters and was familiar with the setting. After the initial action of Claire getting stained by the ink, things slowed down a bit too much for my liking. There was a lot of interpersonal drama, which makes sense because the characters were left unsettled and have to get used to their new positions and roles, but that part wasn’t my favorite. Things picked up once Rami and Hero started to travel to other realms again, but by then the book was half-way through. Also, they returned fairly soon and it meant the story slowed down again.
For me, this was the weakest book in the series. I don’t read nearly enough trilogies to know if hat is a common thing to happen with the middle book.

The God of Lost Words / A.J. Hackwith

Book 3: The God of Lost Words (2021)
And again, the book starts right where the previous one left off.
Hero feels lost without his book, Claire is still upset about her stain, and Brevity is recovering from the betrayal of her sister muse. Then, a new well appears in the library and everybody is on high alert this time. The well doesn’t contain ink though, but clear water, and through it travels Echo, the librarian of the Elysium Library. Rami and Hero had visited there in the previous book and with their presence they had awakened the books in the Elysium Library. Talking stories in an echo place is not a safe space, so the librarian is now seeking a place to hide. They’ve come to the Library of the Unwritten and without so much as a pretty please, bring in their materials.
Another person to visit, is Malphas. This dangerous figure is one of Hell’s generals and sets fire to the Arcane Wing, leaving Claire and Rami to seek refuge in the Library as well. The place is quickly becoming overcrowded, and not necessarily the safe space they all need. Realizing they are sitting ducks and that the best defense is an offence, the crew decides on a plan of attack. With an all-for-one-one-for-all ‘tude they get to working on creating a realm of their own. Which means that they need a space, a god, and a guard. To establish this, they need help from the libraries in the other realms and they set about to get the librarians on board. It’s a reunion with some of the characters from the first book and some new ones. Like in the first book, there is a sense of urgency with this story that keeps the momentum going. During their inter-world librarian meeting Malphas makes her attack and floods the Library of the Unwritten. Everybody is stuck but a plan starts to form and our band of characters jump into action: Rami and Claire lead the negotiations with hell’s general, Brevity uses her muse skills to keep what is left of the library safe, and Hero dives back into the Dust Wing.
The ending was nicely done with the Library telling the finale. It read like a movie.

I didn’t know I needed a trilogy set in hell’s library, but sometimes the books just find you and it’s a great find and all in all I’m really happy having read this trilogy. The library setting is super cool and made me smile plenty. The main characters are pretty kick-ass, and the bittersweet ending was unexpected and gave it all just a little bit extra.

The hell’s library series

Book review: The Cat Who Saved Books / Sosuke Natsukawa

The Cat Who Saved Books / Sosuke Natsukawa

If I could use only one word to describe this book, I would use: adorable.
Thankfully, there is no word count limitation in the world of this bookworm, so here’s everything else I have to say about it.

Rintaro Natsuki is a teenager when his grandfather dies. Suddenly, it’s just him and the Natsuki Books bookshop. This second-hand bookshop sounds amazing; completely unassuming but with a unique collection of collector’s items and a proprietor who knows a lot about books.
Without parents and now without his grandfather as well, Rintaro rightfully feels lost and scared. He quits going to school, and stays back to run the shop until his aunt has made the necessary arrangements to sell the business and take him in. Two of his classmates visit him: the popular and smart Akiba, and class representative and music geek Sayo. They both try to convince him to come back to school, and assure him he’s being missed by his classmates. Rintaro isn’t so sure about that and prefers to stay at the bookshop. So, they make it a mission to regularly check in on him.
Someone else to enter the shop, is Tiger the tabby. This cat isn’t just any tabby, it can talk. And it’s telling Rintaro that he needs to go on a mission. A mission to save books from people who mistreat them. Rintaro doesn’t know what else to do, and simply follows the cat through a doorway that hadn’t existed before, only to find himself emerge on the other side inside the big home of a book collector. The man claims to care so much for books that he locks them in cabinets, behind bars. Rintaro has to discover why this is wrong, what the threat is, and how to resolve it.
Sayo happens to be in the shop when Tiger the tabby appears for the second mission. She won’t hear “no” and joins Rintaro and Tiger on the mission.

There is a total of four labyrinths for Rintaro to finish. In between challenges he is back at the shop, faced with the painful reality of life. Although hesitant and scared during the first mission, he’s happy to dive in by the time mission number three is announced.

The only thing in this book I had a bit of trouble with, was the timeline. At one point it’s made clear that everybody is concerned about Rintaro still grieving and not feeling up to joining daily life, because it had been two whole days since his grandfather’s memorial which seemed extreme to me. I’m jotting this down to cultural differences.

This book is a very nicely written modern fairy tale. True to fairy-tale style the moral of the story is loud and unmistakable, but it’s so nicely done that I’m willing to accept that.
If you like to read fairy-tales, fantasy, anything to do with books, reading, or cats, you’ll like this book.